New analysis from the Israeli Health Ministry concluded Pfizer's COVID vaccine killed"about 40 times more(elderly)people than the disease itself would have killed"during a recent five-week vaccination period,and 260 times more younger people than would have died from the virus.


While in January a group of independent doctors concluded that experimental COVID-19 vaccines are"not safer"than the virus itself,a new analysis of vaccine-related death rates in Israel demonstrates that this may indeed be the case to dramatic levels.


A re-analysis of published data from the Israeli Health Ministry by Dr.Hervé Seligmann,a member of the faculty of Medicine Emerging Infectious and Tropical Diseases at Aix-Marseille University,and engineer Haim Yativ reveal,in short,that the mRNA experimental vaccine from Pfizer killed"about 40 times more(elderly)people than the disease itself would have killed"during a recent five-week vaccination period.Among the younger class,these numbers are compounded to death rates at 260 times what the COVID-19 virus would have claimed in the given time frame.

艾克斯-马赛大学医学新兴传染病和热带疾病学院的 hervé Seligmann 博士和工程师 Haim Yativ 对以色列卫生部公布的数据进行了重新分析,简而言之,辉瑞公司的 mRNA 实验疫苗在最近五周的疫苗接种期间造成的死亡人数比疾病本身造成的死亡人数多40倍。在年轻一代中,这些数字加起来的死亡率是2019冠状病毒疾病病毒在给定时间范围内的死亡率的260倍。

While the full mathematical analysis may be found in the article itself,the authors demonstrate how among"those vaccinated and above 65,0.2%…died during the three-week period between doses,hence about 200 among 100,000 vaccinated.This is to be compared to the 4.91 dead among 100,000 dying from COVID-19 without vaccination."


"This scary picture also extends to those below 65,"the researchers continued.During the five-week vaccination process"0.05%,meaning 50 among 100,000,died.This is to be compared to the 0.19 per 100,000 dying from COVID-19(who)are not vaccinated…Hence the death rate of this age group increased by 260(times)during this five-week period of the vaccination process,as compared to their natural COVID-19 death rate."


As reported by IsraelNationalNews(INN),Seligmann is of Israeli-Luxembourg nationality,has a biology degree from Hebrew University of Jerusalem,and has written more than 100 scientific publications.INN reports the researchers"have no conflicts or interests other than having children in Israel."


Yativ and Seligmann stipulate that even these"estimated numbers of deaths from the vaccine are probably much lower than actual numbers as it accounts only for those defined as COVID-19 deaths for that short time period and does not include AVC and cardiac(and other)events resulting from the inflammatory reactions."

Yativ 和 Seligmann 规定,即使这些"估计的疫苗死亡人数也可能远远低于实际数字,因为它只包括那些在短时间内被定义为2019冠状病毒疾病死亡的人,而不包括由炎症反应导致的动静脉畸形和心脏(以及其他)事件。"

Nor do these numbers"account for long-term complications,"they write.


In addition,within several months they expect"mid-and long-term adverse effects of the vaccination as ADE(Antibody-dependent Enhancement)"begins to become manifest in those who have received the experimental Pfizer vaccine.

此外,在几个月内,他们预计"中期和长期的不良反应疫苗接种作为 ADE(抗体依赖性增强作用)"开始成为明显的那些已经接受实验辉瑞疫苗。

As explained by America's Frontline Doctors(AFLDS),ADE"is when anti-COVID antibodies,created by a vaccine,instead of protecting the person,cause a more severe or lethal disease when the person is later exposed to SARS-CoV-2 in the wild.The vaccine amplifies the infection rather than preventing damage."

正如美国前线医生(AFLDS)解释的那样,ADE"是指当人后来在野外暴露于 SARS-CoV-2时,由疫苗产生的抗Covid 抗体,而不是保护人体,导致更严重或致命的疾病。这种疫苗加重了感染,而不是防止了损害。"

AFLDS provides an example of a vaccine produced to fight the Dengue fever,which resulted in deaths of 600 children in the Philippines due to ADE,and the filing of criminal charges against the decision-makers in 2019.


For these reasons and more,AFLDS and many other doctors strongly discourage the use of these experimental vaccines for most people while only acknowledging that it may be plausible for those over 70 years of age,yet acknowledging that such injections are"a higher risk than early or prophylactic treatment with established medications"(sources here, here, here, and here).

由于这些原因以及更多的原因,AFLDS 和许多其他医生强烈反对大多数人使用这些实验性疫苗,同时只承认这对70岁以上的人来说可能是合理的,但也承认这种注射"比早期或使用现有药物进行预防性治疗的风险更高"(来源是这里、这里、这里和这里)。

Given these death rates,Yativ and Seligmann also have harsh criticism for the severe pressure being imposed upon the population by Israeli authorities to receive these shots.According to INN,the researchers call these draconian efforts"a new Holocaust."

鉴于这些死亡率,Yativ 和 Seligmann 也受到严厉批评,因为以色列当局对居民施加了接受这些射击的严厉压力。国际犹太人学院称,研究人员将这些严酷的努力称为"新的大屠杀"

In the past weeks,Israel's government made headlines when they adopted a"green pass"system,allowing people who have been injected to receive a green code,which then grants them entry into places such as entertainment and leisure facilities.


As the country reopens after a two-month lockdown,the green pass would be given only to those who had been injected,not to people who tested negative for the virus.The proposed benefits include access to"non-essential"businesses as well as not being required to self-isolate if identified as a close contact of a confirmed case of COVID-19,and not having to self-isolate after a return from what the government calls a"red location."


Despite there being no proof that these experimental vaccines actually prevent transmission of the virus,Israel's minister for health,Yuli Edelstein,said upon the release of the vaccine"passport"that"(g)etting vaccinated is a moral duty.It is part of our mutual responsibility."He went further,declaring,"Whoever does not get vaccinated will be left behind."

尽管没有证据表明这些实验性疫苗实际上能够阻止病毒的传播,但以色列卫生部长 Yuli Edelstein 在疫苗"护照"发放时表示,"(g)接种疫苗是一种道德义务。这是我们共同责任的一部分。"他更进一步,宣称:"不接种疫苗的人将被留下。"

The green pass needs renewing every six months,and despite holding one,an individual must still abide by masking and physical distancing rules.The Jerusalem Post also reported that legislation is being considered to grant employers the right to refuse unvaccinated people entry into the workplace.


Such measures prompted Business Insider to describe the country as"waging a war on the unvaccinated."Meanwhile,Dr.Anthony Fauci,chief medical adviser to President Joe Biden,has styled Israel's vaccination response as"extraordinarily good."



近 31 日
0 次瀏覽
本訊息有 1 則查核回應
MrOrz 認為 含有錯誤訊息
引用自 MrOrz 查核回應
這是 2021 年 3 月的舊訊息。「以色列衛生部」並沒有說輝瑞疫苗殺死的老人是 COVID-19 的 40 倍。

🇮🇱 查核組織 Snopes 指出,以色列衛生部門並沒有做出謠言內文裡寫的這些分析。2021 年 3 月初時,以色列就已經替超過一半的國民注射至少一劑的輝瑞疫苗,並且在一月發表報告表示大部分的疫苗副作用輕微,且不會持續很久。

👩‍🏫 查核組織 Science Feedback 則表示,該網傳文章的數據推論有問題。文中所謂「65 歲以上接種過疫苗的人的死亡率為 0.2%」數據號稱來自疫苗不良事件回報系統(VAERS),但該比例根本不知道怎麼算出來的。網傳文章拿上面的數字與「65 歲以上、未接種過疫苗的死亡數據」(每 100,000 人中 4.91 例)做比較,但這個數據表格的旁邊,就有「65 歲以上、完整接種疫苗後的死亡數據」(每 100,000 人中 0.279 例),比例根本遠低於「沒有接種過疫苗的死亡數據」,但網傳文章作者做比較的時候,卻無來由的直接無視該數據。


2021/3/5 Snopes - No, the Israeli Health Ministry Didn’t Say the Pfizer Vaccine ‘Killed 40 Times More Elderly’ Than COVID-19

2021/3/9 Science Feedback - Data from Israel showed that the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine reduces the likelihood of dying from COVID-19; analysis in a forum post claiming the opposite is flawed

No, the Israeli Health Ministry Didn't Say the Pfizer Vaccine 'Killed 40 Times More Elderly' Than COVID-19

The Israeli Health Ministry did not say that the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine kills a whopping 40 times more elderly people than the pandemic virus.

1 則回應被作者自行刪除。

以上內容「Cofacts 真的假的」訊息回報機器人與查證協作社群提供,以 CC授權 姓名標示-相同方式分享 4.0 (CC BY-SA 4.0) 釋出,於後續重製或散布時,原社群顯名及每一則查證的出處連結皆必須被完整引用。

加 LINE 查謠言
加 LINE 查謠言
LINE 機器人